A while back, on the Book of Face, I ran into this photo with the attached astute caption:

I commented that the reason the US has the largest prison system in the history of planet Earth–bigger than the Gulag Archipelago, bigger than the PRC’s–is that American capitalism could not bear to really give up all the free labor it derived from slavery. MAGA antichrist religion loves this system. Loves it.
Jesus, meanwhile, began his ministry this way:
And he came to Nazareth, where he had been brought up; and he went to the synagogue, as his custom was, on the sabbath day. And he stood up to read; and there was given to him the book of the prophet Isaiah. He opened the book and found the place where it was written,
“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me,
because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor.
He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives
and recovering of sight to the blind,
to set at liberty those who are oppressed,
to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord.”And he closed the book, and gave it back to the attendant, and sat down; and the eyes of all in the synagogue were fixed on him. And he began to say to them, “Today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing.” (Luke 4:16-21)
Sure as shooting, an obvious sock puppet showed up in my comboxes from an account with a generic name (“John Cooper”), no posts at all and a single photo to offer fake “expertise”, to make excuses for the Cult and to pretend to ask questions, not for the purpose of finding anything out, but in order to keep from finding anything out:
If the American prison system was all about money, then private prisons would be much more common than they are. Also, the Second Circuit, where Albany County is (if t’s NY), has ruled that inmates have to paid to work and that no one can be forced to work (which would violate the constitutional prohibition against slavery). As someone who used to have some involvement in a state prison system, I can tell you that inmates generally wanted jobs even though they pay was modest.
Mark. can you provide documentation for your claims here?
I supplied this link (with the information below it):
America has the largest prison population in the world:
Incarceration is the state of being confined in prison, typically as punishment for a crime. Every country in the world has a prison system of some sort, though the exact nature of that system—as well as the number of prisoners incarcerated within it—varies tremendously from country to country. The United States leads the world in total number of people incarcerated, with more than 2 million prisoners nationwide (per data released in October 2021 by World Prison Brief). This number is equivalent to roughly 25% of the world’s total prison population and leads to an incarceration rate of 629 people per 100,000—the highest rate in the world. The prison populations in each U.S. state vary from one to the next, with the highest rates in Louisiana and Oklahoma. Overall, the incarceration rate in the U.S. has skyrocketed in the past decade—the prison population was a mere 200,000 in 1972, less than a tenth of today’s total. However, the current rate is the lowest it has been in 20 years.


I then added:
If you are asking the reason why we have such a colossal prison population, it is not (just as it is not with our gun slaughter rate) because Americans are peculiarly mentally ill or criminal in ways the rest of the world are not, but because our legal regime is deliberately engineered to create this outcome (as is explained THE NEW JIM CROW: MASS INCARCERATION IN THE AGE OF COLORBLINDNESS) for reasons deeply rooted in our racist and economic history that the entire MAGA cult and GOP (and its white Christian nationalist antichrist religion base) lives to deny.
Well, my MAGA reader had no intention of actually getting an answer, because he already had his own intensely racist answer:
America is a high crime nation. It’s in large part because we have a a black population which is genetically predisposed to crime. What explanation is there for the fact that one group of the population commits crime at ten times the rate of the rest? As the left-wing geneticist David Reich put it, when the genes that influence intelligence and behavior are found, they will inevitably vary from race to race because the genes for everything else do.
Right. The problem is genetic inferiority, No wonder the Master Race needs to jail them when they are mere children over the stupidest trivialities. Clearly the problem is with these born criminal and not with centuries-old legal, economic, and political structures of sin.

Gentle reader: I provided you with the explanation in the form of the book THE NEW JIM CROW. Instead of using the information you were only pretending to ask for, you showed your rhetorical cards by sticking to your lying, racist guns and parroting eugenicist lies and propaganda like the MAGA cult always does when confronted with facts you don’t like. Goodbye, bigot. Repent.
14 Responses
thanks for continuing to put stuff out there – praying for better understanding and caring
Patrick Troughton (British actor who played the second incarnation of Doctor Who in the late Sixties) used to urinate on golf courses to make a political point. Can you imagine anyone suggesting he be locked up for that?
My latest issue of Imprimis (published by Hillsdale College for potential benefactors) was all about how racial quotas for employment were ruining civilization, which quickly pivoted to blacks disproportionately commit most crimes, etc. It’s worth a read, Mark, if you want more material to debunk on this topic.
I’m white and have no problem believing that Chinese are naturally better at math. My wife’s a teacher and she sees it all the time.
What an elaborately passive-aggressive way to say, “Why yes, I *do* endorse the claim that Blacks are just genertically inferior!”
@Mark:
Right? The sophistry is just sickening.
Most experts in the field of intelligence research agree that the high IQ of Ashkenazi Jews has a genetic component.
It’s amazing the way racists consistently use this elaborate passive-aggressive strategy to avoid coming out and saying, “Why yes. I *do* think black people are genetically inferior” which is what you actually mean.
That’s a complete non-sequitur. Let’s assume that Blacks are genetically inferior for the sake of an argument. I’m not saying they are and I don’t have a horse in that race, since I’m not American.
Stating this as a fact doesn’t carry any implications. It certainly doesn’t justify subjugating Blacks or denying them rights.
But denying and suppressing facts is a lot worse. Especially if it’s done because somebody’s feelings are hurt.
Suppose somebody denied and suppressed the fact that Jesus rose from the dead and demanded that you stop spreading this fact because it makes them feel bad. We’re forced to automatically comply with any demands to suppress facts that make people feel bad.
<>
LOL you chose this conversation to give us all a lecture about suppressing facts?
News flash. It is not a fact. It is a falsehood. We are totally in the right and can choose whatever tactic we deem fit to fight falsehood, up to and including making liars feel bad.
GULAG imprisoned millions of people. It’s hard to get the exact numbers due to falsification and disposal of documents, but latest estimates put the number at about 5 million constant GULAG population, with a total of tens of millions of inmates (considering that only a handful was released, the rest just died).
“Reeducation” camps in China under Mao were even worse.
Comparing the American prison system with these is simply disingenuous.
The larger point is though: why do so many people have to go to an American prison in the first place? As Mark points out, the reason is profit. And where can we find all these lawbreakers to put into prison? The fact that minority populations are more highly policed and prosecuted than white populations is a glaring pattern that Americans need to examine.
As I said, I don’t have a horse in this race, I’m not American. I’m not going to be lecturing you from an ivory tower.
Minorities are more highly policed and prosecuted simply because the majority population is more willing to turn a blind eye to their plight and because the majority feel like “hosts” and treat minorities like “guests”.
The failure of American justice system and how it needs to produce outcomes in terms of number of incarcerated to show that it’s working is a different matter.
However, while on the topic of minorities, how come Asian-Americans make up 5.9% of US ethnics, but only 1.5% of US prison population?
You really are pressing hard for that whole “racial inferiority” thing, aren’t you?