A brief memo to Bishops Cordileone, Dolan, Paprocki, and Rhoades

Congrats on your appointment to Trump’s sham Religious Liberty Commission.

Here’s the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church

According to the plan of God brought about in Christ, there corresponds to the identity and mission of the Church in the world “a saving and eschatological purpose which can be fully attained only in the next life.” Precisely for this reason, the Church offers an original and irreplaceable contribution with the concern that impels her to make the family of mankind and its history more human, prompting her to PLACE HERSELF AS A BULWARK AGAINST EVERY TOTALITARIAN TEMPTATION, as she shows man his integral and definitive vocation.

Meanwhile, the dictator you have chosen to serve by lending the prestige of your office takes all his real cues from men like Elon Musk, who says:

“The fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy.”

or Peter Thiel:

The tyrant you have chosen to legitimate with your service regards you as tools and prey. He sees you as this highly typical post-Christian conservative does:

So consider the possibility that the call from the enemies of religious liberty is coming from inside the house and realize that, increasingly, the MAGA spirit of antichrist is emerging like the chestburster in ALIEN from the last gooey trappings of Christianesque piety it once used to disguise itself. It’s just a matter of time till the Christians who lied themselves into believing that Trump and his toadies gave a shit about them find themselves betrayed as he betrays everyone he no longer needs. It will be fascinating to see if MAGA Christians go on lying to themselves to preserve their pride from facing how desperately they have sinned or if they finally crack and say to the Father, “I have sinned against you.”

Share

9 Responses

  1. I suspect that Trump has nothing but contempt for his “base” the religious right. All the phony piety, the Evangelical Preachers invited to the White House to “pray.” But of course, actions speak louder than words and the actions are to cut Medicad, SNAP and other programs for the poor. Deport immigrants and generally treat the less fortunate badly. And of course, wrap this throwing the poor under the bus, with the flag and phony religious piety.

    MAGA people have been bamboozled. Trump has great contempt for the working class in flyover country. They are easily conned. Tell them that they are the “real Americans,” throw them a few culture war bones, and they obey “Dear Leader.” They gulp the Kool Aid.

    Will the religious right ever wake up? Some of them perhaps, but for many, they simply cannot admit that they have been bamboozled by an obvious con man. For a working class white guy in a dead end job, making $12/hr to endorse tax cuts for the rich is quite a con. Can he admit that he was scammed? We shall see.

  2. I see it slightly differently. Just as love conquered the pagan Romans not violence or anything else, I think that love will conquer MAGA. And who better to assist in it then our Catholic leaders? Yea I admit it’s definitely hopeful and perhaps naive. But we just have to keep reminding our leaders of the perennial social teachings of the Church.

  3. Please see Archbishop Wester’s article in America, published June 3. He explicitly invokes Catholic Social Teaching many times to oppose the Big Beautiful Bill. Yes to our blogger’s name-checking of these four bishops, but also yes to the public critique of the regime from other bishops.

  4. In a complete non-sequitur, I just saw something posted weeks ago on an instagram profile called @sacredchad:
    > ‘How to become Catholic’ searches rose 370% after Pope Francis’s death.

    The moment I saw it, my first thought was that people were moved by his his life’s witness and his death was, for them, a breaking point, a watershed, that may bring them to Christ.

    Apparently, the viewpoint is that Francis was the thing holding people back from converting to Catholicism… By that logic, people who were moved by the death of Jesus, then by the witness of the Apostles, only joined the Church because they actually despised Jesus and could only join once He was no longer in the picture.

  5. I have to admit that I have never hear of any of the four bishops you name as having been appointed to Trump’s Religious Liberty Commission. Please explain the errors or at least provide a link so I can educate myself.

    1. Just google the 4 names together. https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=Cordileone%2C+Dolan%2C+Paprocki%2C+and+Rhoades&sei=pwpDaLjSNPCmkPIPndrWmAY Dolan is the archbishop of NY who was laughing it up with Trump at that Al Smith dinner that made headlines because Harris sent them a video and didn’t attend. That WH faith office is headed by Paula White a millionaire tele-evangelist who “advises” Trump on faith issues. Also known for “speaking in tongues” and hawking cash for blessings. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/05/paula-white-faith-office-trump

  6. A second grader could figure out who is kind and worthy of trust when presented with our global problems.

    That’s why Jesus grabbed a kid and said: “be more like him”.

Leave a Reply

Follow Mark on Twitter and Facebook

Get updates by email

NEW BOOK!

Advertisement

Discover more from Stumbling Toward Heaven

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading